For all those of who who missed the action, here are the bare facts condensed in a single sentence (the video is there too at the end of the post). At a press conference in Delhi, Dainik Jagran journalist, Jarnail Singh threw his shoe at the Home Minister Mr. P. Chidambaram in protest against the latter's refusal to answer questions relating to the CBI's role in the Jagdish Tytler case.
Technically though, the attempt cannot be described as a throw; it was more of a gentle underarm lob. But it did threaten to almost make contact with the honourable minister's face (which, I am pretty sure, was definitely not what the valiant Sikh wanted). For a very brief period during the white shoe's graceful trajectory, P. Chidambaram must have had strange but delightful visions of flying idlis heading towards him. But the realization of the embarrassment that might result if the missile found its target brought him to his senses. And in a surprising display of agility hitherto unseen in an elderly Indian politician, Mr. Chidambaram deftly evaded the said missile. The hawkish concentration with which his eyes followed the shoe as it passed him would have been a lesson for any top-order batsman in evading a bouncer. The Home Minister, who also happens to be an MBA from the Harvard Business School, quickly regained his Zen-like composure, managed a confused smile and in true Gandhian spirit proclaimed,
I forgive him...let not the action of one emotional person hijack the entire press conference. I have answered his question to the best of my ability
All of which brings us to the question of whether Jarnail Singh's preferred mode of protest is indeed justified. The missile in this case happened to be a sneaker which has a relatively low chance of causing grievous bodily harm. But it may not be long before a fanatic decides to hurl a clog or a skate shoe or 4-inch heels at his/her victim. Other than the obvious risk of physical injury, there is also the chance of hurting sensibilities. Everyone cannot be a George Bush or a P. Chidambaram in his reactions. The Chinese Premier Wen Jiabao, for instance, let his displeasure known in describing his recent shoeing incident as "despicable". In this age of touchy international relations, it doesn't take much for a trivial issue to snowball into a major row. And with enough troubles in the world already, we do not really need any more.
There surely must be more civilised and creative methods of protest to get your point across. Suggestions anyone?
Here is the TV footage of the incident in question.







17 comments:
ya i saw it on tv. he did not aim at the minister just threw it casually and was also interviewed on NDTV 9'o clock news.
hahaha.....Jarnail Singh's 5 minutes under the spotlight...thanks to his shoe and chidambaram.
What I dislike most in this episode is the media's inability to keep its balance. Increasingly this is happening whether in the form of a choking to tears Barakha at Mumbai or a shoe throwing Jarnail.
The media has to remember that their weapon has to be the pen not the shoe or theatrics.
' forgive them lord.. for they know not why they sin..' i guess CHIT-DAM-Brrm read the scriptures well enough to know that the quality of mercy is heavy!! n again william sha'peare said.. quality of mercy is twice blessed.. blesseth him that gives, n him that takes... this darn political tomfoolery... Mr SIngh should have thrown the other one and i read he is a pretty gud cruc fan n player.. tatz his 'udarota' that he let the missile miss the man... democracy and politics in this country are really gone to the shoe-laces now!! open and throw!
Sorry Sujoy, but I'm too tickled at the incident to really offer sensible feedback in any form !
yeah atleast if the journalist had thrown some eggs, chiddu uncle could have had his breakfast - high in protein!!! :P
This post has been removed by the author.
@zendagi migzara
Mr. Singh is a minor celebrity now. And like they say,'Any publicity is good publicity'. Dainik Jagran's must be secretly giving Jarnail Singh a raise for this free publicity.
@Pinku
All these theatrics do nothing more than trivializing the issue. The entire incident was so religiously discussed with slow-mo videos and crappy graphics that the reason for the protest was all but forgotten. Instead of explaining Jarnail Singh's angst, what we find is a comparative analysis of the attacks on George Bush and Chidambaram. Pathetic!
@der Bergwind
"tatz his 'udarota' that he let the missile miss the man"...that is pretty much what everyone watching the incident felt. And it must have taken a lot of self-control to restrain himself.
@Casuarina
For all its negatives, there is one thing Indian politics cannot be accused of - dullness.
@lafemmereva
Scrambled egg breakfast,eh?
well, a shoe throw made janail richer by 2 lacs, so who needs a polite or civilised protest when uncivilised and copycat protest can earn you instant fame and mollah....However, if u are really looking for a suggestion, then I think a Munnabhai propogated a prtest would be to send a pair of shoes everyday to Chidambaram's shoes....what say? www.ripplesofwords.blogspot.com
hello sujoy
this is really amazing. i was planning to write about Jarnail singh myself.looks like you beat me to it. :)
i think the worst part is that the congress is taking action on Tytler now, after the incident, rather than earlier as it should have. this is going to give out a message that if you want to have your point heard, all you need to do is fling a shoe. this is bound to set a very bad precedent.
As for poor Chidu's reaction, well, what else could he do but deal with it in good humour? he had to salvage what little dignity the incident left him. his reaction was better than bush's, who just managed to laugh goofily. (i wrote a poem on that, it went like this-
"Jawar mukhe marlo jooto,
Accha okritogyo to!
Taarai sheshe chhetaaye thutu
Jaader jonyo korchi eto...")
Your description was hilarious.
and thank you for having the patience to go through my book list. yes, you see, all i do is read, so i do have a rather eclectic taste. but you are right, i haven't gotten my hands on a graphic novel yet... maybe you can suggest one?
if you liked my blog, please do become a follower so that you can read when i write next and give me feedback. thank you :)
i'll be watching this space for your next post.
I don't think that the shoe should have been thrown at Chidambaram. After all, the poor man had nothing to do with Sikhs. Jarnail could have landed himself in greater trouble by his action, like the Iraqi journalist who has been sentenced to a jail-term for a year.
@Anorak
the suggestion is great.....may be I should go about making unacceptable statements about controversial topics. I badly need a shoe
@little girl lost
Thanks for visiting my blog....couldn't really appreciate the poetry as I am not really good at bengali(I know it is a shame)...
as for graphic novels...persepolis or maus would be a good starting point
@butterfly
yeah but he could have, atleast, answered the queries....nothing pisses off a man more than indifference
2 lakhs for the best shoe thrown.
Well..if this shoe hurling stuff goes on..no wonder if journalists are made to remove their shoes before going to any press conference.
As Jarnail Singh has alreday said, "Method was wrong, issue is right."
This post has been removed by the author.
@Dhrubo
For the best shoe thrown or the best throw?
@Tanaya
It is not only journalist, the guy who chucked his shoe at Naveen Jindal was a school-teacher.
But yes, it was a journalist who showed the way.
School-teachers and journalist, not bad people to emulate, eh?
@exposemaximum
Hindsight is a wonderful thing, makes you wiser than you actually are :)
Post a Comment